India's Green Law Needs Baselines, Not Snapshots

Advertisement

 

India's Green Law Needs Baselines, Not Snapshots

Source: The Hindu

Why in news?

The Supreme Court's 22 August decision overturned the National Green Tribunal's (NGT) December 2017 judgment on the Art of Living's World Culture Festival. The festival was held from 11 to 13 March 2016 on 25 hectares of the Yamuna floodplain in Delhi. The NGT had ordered ₹5 crore as environmental compensation. The Supreme Court ordered a refund, asking whether the organisers had caused additional damage to an already degraded floodplain.

Static background

  • NGT Act, 2010: Created the NGT to decide environmental cases quickly. It applies sustainable development, the precautionary principle and the polluter pays principle. Section 15 deals with relief, compensation and restoration.
  • Polluter pays principle: Those who cause environmental harm bear the cost of remedying it. It was accepted in Indian law in Indian Council for Enviro-Legal Action v. Union of India (1996) and Vellore Citizens Welfare Forum v. Union of India (1996).
  • Article 21 includes the right to a healthy environment, and Articles 48A and 51A(g) set the State's and citizens' duties.
  • Floodplains absorb floodwater and recharge groundwater. The NGT's 2015 order in Manoj Misra v. Union of India was about protecting the Yamuna floodplain.

The Supreme Court's decision and the polluter pays principle

  • The principle holds that those responsible for environmental damage bear compensation and restoration costs. Liability must rest on demonstrable responsibility, not mere occupation of land.
  • The central question was whether the festival caused additional damage or the destruction already existed.
  • The Court stressed that environmental penalties need evidence of causation and individual responsibility.
  • The approach is legally sound, but uncertainty should not become an excuse to escape environmental accountability.

A tribunal that decided too early

 

1. Premature finding of liability

  • On 9 March 2016, two days before the festival, the NGT allowed the event after directing the organisers to deposit ₹5 crore and bear restoration costs if damage was proved.
  • It also declared the floodplain drastically altered, without adequate reasons or a thorough investigation.

2. Pre-existing degradation

  • An April 2014 expert report described the floodplain as ruined, and the NGT's July 2015 order recorded that earlier restoration directions were not implemented.
  • In December 2015, construction debris across 25-30 acres was reported, and the Delhi Development Authority allowed its removal.

3. Restoration versus ecological upgradation

  • The investigating committee admitted it could not establish the site's original ecological condition, yet recommended major improvement, including a biodiversity park that had never existed there.
  • Restoration returns an ecosystem to its earlier condition, while upgradation improves it beyond that. Section 15 of the NGT Act provides for restoration, not automatically for creating new ecological facilities.

 

 

Major Environmental Legislations in India

These laws can be linked to the issue of environmental monitoring and regulatory enforcement.

Legislation

Static relevance

Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972

Protection of wild animals, birds and plants; protected areas.

Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974

Prevention and control of water pollution.

Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980

Regulation of diversion of forest land for non-forest purposes; now renamed Van (Sanrakshan Evam Samvardhan) Adhiniyam, 1980.

Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981

Prevention, control and abatement of air pollution.

Environment (Protection) Act, 1986

Umbrella legislation empowering the Central Government to protect and improve environmental quality.

Biological Diversity Act, 2002

Conservation of biodiversity, sustainable use and fair and equitable benefit-sharing.

National Green Tribunal Act, 2010

Provides for specialised adjudication of environmental disputes.

5. Important Institutions and Their Functions

  • Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB): Monitors and coordinates pollution-control activities.
  • State Pollution Control Boards (SPCBs): Implement pollution-control measures at the state level.
  • National Green Tribunal (NGT): Adjudicates environmental disputes and provides relief and compensation.
  • Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC): Formulates environmental policies and administers major environmental laws.
  • National Biodiversity Authority (NBA): Regulates access to biological resources and associated knowledge under the Biological Diversity Act.

 

 

Conclusion

Environmental accountability needs evidence of the land's condition before use. Mandatory baseline surveys, together with equitable apportionment under Section 17(2), would let the polluter pays principle work without punishing the innocent or excusing the harmful.