VAID'S ICS – Best UPSC Anthropology Coaching in Delhi Since 1985

Comprehensive Classroom Course · Admissions openRegister now
+91 93113 37737
  • +91-93113 37737, +91-99999 46748
  • 73(FF), Old Rajender Nagar Market, Delhi - 110060
  • MON to SUN 9.00 am - 6.00 pm
Facebook Youtube Instagram
Menu
Enquire Now
Home/Anthropology/Mains PYQ/2024/Paper II/Tribal Problems & Displacement
UPSC MainsAnthropology Optional Paper II 2024 20 Marks Model Answer Available

Holistic Health Paradigms for Marginalised Sections after COVID-19 — 2024 Paper II

Question · 2024 · Paper II · 20 Marks

Critically examine existing paradigms of holistic health for the marginalised sections of society drawing inferences from COVID-19 pandemic.

Model Answer

VAID ICS

Introduction In medical anthropology, "holistic health" transcends the mere absence of disease; it is the integration of biological, ecological, socio-cultural, and political-economic well-being. The COVID-19 pandemic acted as a "total social fact" (Marcel Mauss), revealing that a virus may be purely biological, but a pandemic is a profoundly social phenomenon. It disproportionately devastated marginalized sections (Dalits, Tribals, urban poor, migrants), exposing the severe limitations of our existing health paradigms.

Critical Examination of Existing Health Paradigms

  1. The Biomedical Model (Reductionist Paradigm)
  • The Paradigm: Focuses purely on the pathogen (SARS-CoV-2), clinical diagnosis, and pharmaceutical intervention (vaccines, antivirals).
  • Critique: Anthropologist Arthur Kleinman distinguishes between disease (biological malfunction) and illness (the lived experience). The biomedical model successfully created vaccines but ignored the socio-economic realities of marginalized groups (e.g., "social distancing" is impossible in a Dharavi slum; washing hands is a luxury where water is scarce).
  1. Political Economy of Health & "Structural Violence"
  • The Paradigm: Paul Farmer’s concept of "Structural Violence" argues that historical and institutional inequalities (caste, class, gender) physically harm marginalized bodies, determining who gets sick and who receives care.
  • Critique: During COVID-19, the sudden lockdowns structurally violently stripped migrant workers of their livelihoods. Their subsequent mass migration and starvation demonstrated that poverty and state policies were as lethal as the pathogen itself.
  1. The Syndemic Paradigm
  • The Paradigm: Coined by Merrill Singer, a "syndemic" occurs when two or more diseases interact synergistically, exacerbated by social inequality.
  • Critique: COVID-19 was not a pandemic but a syndemic. In marginalized Indian communities, COVID-19 interacted lethally with existing pre-conditions like tuberculosis, malnutrition, anemia, and diabetes, multiplying the mortality rate among the poor.
  1. Medical Pluralism and Ethnomedicine
  • The Paradigm: Acknowledges the simultaneous use of biomedicine, AYUSH, and folk healing practices.
  • Critique: During the pandemic, when the biomedical infrastructure collapsed, marginalized sections relied heavily on traditional ethnomedicine (e.g., immunity-boosting herbal decoctions / Kadha). However, state health paradigms often marginalized these practices or failed to scientifically integrate them, leading to both delayed medical interventions and the loss of valid indigenous knowledge.
  1. The "One Health" Approach
  • The Paradigm: Views human, animal, and ecological health as interconnected—crucial for understanding zoonotic spillovers like COVID-19.
  • Critique: While ecologically sound, it often ignores human power dynamics. For instance, regulating wet markets or wildlife trade often criminalizes the subsistence strategies of indigenous forest-dwelling tribes without offering alternative livelihoods.

Inferences and Lessons from COVID-19 for Marginalized Sections

  • Technological Exclusion (Biopolitics): The initial reliance on digital platforms (like the CoWIN portal) for vaccination registration systematically excluded digitally illiterate, undocumented, and rural populations.
  • Cultural Incompetence: Centralized pandemic management ignored local socio-cultural realities. The imposition of strict burial/cremation protocols caused deep psychological trauma and alienation among communities where death rituals are vital for community healing.
  • The Burden on Community Health Workers: The pandemic response rested heavily on underpaid women (ASHA and Anganwadi workers). This highlighted a gendered exploitation within the public health paradigm, where grassroots caregivers are denied formal employee status.
  • Disruption of Routine Health: The hyper-focus on COVID-19 collapsed routine health services. Marginalized pregnant women faced high maternal mortality, and tribal children missed routine immunizations, showing the fragility of a non-holistic health system.

Way Forward: Re-imagining a Holistic Paradigm To build a resilient health system for the marginalized, India must adopt a Bio-cultural and Community-centric approach:

  1. Decentralization: Empowering Gram Sabhas and local Panchayats to manage health crises, as seen in the successful "Kerala Model" of community tracing.
  2. Integrating Social Protection: Health policy must be inextricably linked to food security (PDS), clean water (WASH), and occupational safety.
  3. Cultural Translation: Public health messaging must be translated into local tribal dialects and cultural idioms to combat vaccine hesitancy, building trust rather than using policing and coercion.

Conclusion COVID-19 definitively proved that a pathogen does not discriminate, but the health system does. A truly holistic health paradigm cannot rely on biomedicine alone. It must embrace anthropological insights to dismantle structural violence, respect medical pluralism, and ensure that health is treated as a fundamental, equitable human right rather than a market commodity.

2026 Make a critical appraisal of Niyamgiri movement against mining-induced displacement. 2026 Write an account on the prevalence of sickle cell disease among the tribal populations of India. What are the initiatives undertaken by the affected states to tackle with this disease? 2026 What are the major challenges tribal communities are facing in contemporary India? 2025 Examine the environmental and biocultural factors influencing the health of tribals of India.

Want feedback on your answer?

Join the Anthropology workshop or get structured answer-writing guidance from VAID ICS.

Join Workshop Contact VAID ICS

UPSC Anthropology Optional 2024 — Paper II

28 questions

1(d) Artisan tribes of Jharkhand

10 Marks150 words
Syllabus: Paper II > Tribal Situation in India > Socio-economic Characteristics > Artisan tribes; Jharkhand
2024Paper IITribal IndiaModel answer available

5(a) B.K. Roy Burman's concept of 'Buffer Zone'

10 Marks150 words
Syllabus: Paper II > Tribal Administration and Policy > Isolation-Assimilation-Integration > Roy Burman; buffer zone
2024Paper IITribal Development, Policy & SafeguardsModel answer available

1(a) Digitisation of rural economy

10 Marks150 words
Syllabus: Paper II > Indian Village > Economy and Change > Digitisation of the rural economy
2024Paper IIVillage India, Urbanisation & Social ChangeModel answer available

1(b) Origin of State Societies

10 Marks150 words
Syllabus: Paper II > Political Organization > State Formation > Origin of state societies
2024Paper IIEconomic & Political AnthropologyModel answer available

5(d) Status of Sixth Schedule Areas

10 Marks150 words
Syllabus: Paper II > Constitutional Safeguards > Fifth and Sixth Schedules > Sixth Schedule areas
2024Paper IITribal Development, Policy & SafeguardsModel answer available

1(c) Syro-Malabar Christians

10 Marks150 words
Syllabus: Paper II > Impact of Religions on Indian Society > Christianity > Syro-Malabar Christians
2024Paper IIIndian Society, Caste & CivilizationModel answer available