VAID'S ICS – Best UPSC Anthropology Coaching in Delhi Since 1985

Comprehensive Classroom Course · Admissions openRegister now
+91 93113 37737
  • +91-93113 37737, +91-99999 46748
  • 73(FF), Old Rajender Nagar Market, Delhi - 110060
  • MON to SUN 9.00 am - 6.00 pm
Facebook Youtube Instagram
Menu
Enquire Now
Home/Anthropology/Mains PYQ/2024/Paper I/Anthropological Theories
UPSC MainsAnthropology Optional Paper I 2024 15 Marks Model Answer Available

Levi-Strauss, the Myth of Asdiwal and Structuralism — 2024 Paper I

Question · 2024 · Paper I · 15 Marks

How does Levi-Strauss look at the Tsimshian myth of Asdiwal? Critically discuss Levi-Strauss' theory of structuralism in the light of his study of mythologies.

Model Answer

VAID ICS

Introduction

Claude Lévi-Strauss developed the structural analysis of mythology in “The Structural Study of Myth” (1955) and demonstrated it through the Tsimshian myth in La Geste d’Asdiwal (1958), later translated as “The Story of Asdiwal.”

Influenced by Saussure and Roman Jakobson, he argued that a myth’s significance lies not merely in its narrative content but in the underlying relations through which the human mind organises reality. Mythical thought, therefore, is logical rather than primitive or irrational.

Structural Method of Myth Analysis

Lévi-Strauss divided myths into basic units of relationship, commonly called mythemes. These become meaningful only when arranged as “bundles of relations.”

A myth is read at two levels:

  • Horizontally: the chronological sequence of events;
  • Vertically: recurring relationships and binary oppositions.

All versions of a myth must be studied together because each version is a transformation of the same underlying structure. Myth moves from an awareness of contradictions towards their attempted mediation.

Tsimshian Myth of Asdiwal

The myth begins during a famine involving a mother and daughter. Asdiwal, born through supernatural intervention, becomes an exceptionally successful hunter. His journeys take him across mountains, river valleys, coastal regions, heaven and the subterranean sea. He contracts successive marriages, faces conflict with affinal relatives and finally becomes trapped on a mountain and turns into stone.

Lévi-Strauss analyses the myth through four interconnected codes.

Geographical Code

Asdiwal’s journeys reproduce the Tsimshian landscape and seasonal movements:

  • east and west;
  • north and south;
  • inland and coast;
  • mountain and sea.

Geographical movement is thus also a movement between opposed cultural categories.

Economic Code

The narrative moves through:

  • famine and abundance;
  • hunting and fishing;
  • mountain game and marine resources;
  • candlefish and salmon seasons.

The myth converts the seasonal subsistence cycle of the Tsimshian into a symbolic structure.

Sociological Code

Asdiwal’s marriages express contradictions involving:

  • endogamy and exogamy;
  • consanguineal and affinal relations;
  • matrilocal and patrilocal residence;
  • husband, wife and brothers-in-law.

His repeated inability to establish stable marital and affinal relations reveals tensions within social organisation.

Cosmological Code

The narrative contrasts:

  • heaven and earth;
  • upper and lower worlds;
  • land and water;
  • mobility and immobility.

Asdiwal crosses these boundaries but cannot permanently reconcile them.

Myth as Failed Mediation

The myth does not simply solve social contradictions. Asdiwal repeatedly attempts to mediate land/sea, high/low, hunting/fishing and alternative residence rules, but every mediation remains incomplete.

His final transformation into stone is structurally significant: the constantly travelling hero becomes permanently immobile. It symbolises the impossibility of fully resolving the contradictions represented in the myth.

Thus, myth provides a logical model through which a society can think about contradictions that cannot be solved in actual life.

Contribution of Lévi-Strauss’s Structuralism

Recognition of the logic of myth

Myths are not meaningless fantasies; they are organised systems of classification.

Relational approach

The meaning of an element depends upon its relationship with other elements, not upon its isolated content.

Integration of cultural domains

The Asdiwal analysis connects geography, subsistence, kinship, residence and cosmology within a common structure.

Transformation of variants

Contradictory versions are analytically valuable because they reveal transformations of the same structure.

Psychic unity of humankind

Recurring binary organisation reflects shared cognitive capacities rather than differences between “primitive” and “civilised” minds.

Critical Evaluation

Selective use of evidence

L.L. Thomas, J.Z. Kronenfeld and D.B. Kronenfeld, in “Asdiwal Crumbles” (1976), argued that Lévi-Strauss selected and rearranged ethnographic details to fit his proposed structure.

Reductionism

Complex social realities may be reduced to neat binary oppositions. Some oppositions may arise from the anthropologist’s analysis rather than indigenous thought.

Neglect of history

Structuralism treats myths as relatively timeless systems and gives inadequate attention to migration, colonialism and historical change.

Neglect of performance and agency

It focuses on myth as a text while overlooking the narrator, audience, occasion, emotion and changing political purpose of narration.

Difficulty of verification

Several different structures may be constructed from the same narrative, making structural interpretation difficult to test objectively.

Neglect of power and gender

The approach emphasises mental classification more than inequality, gender relations and the interests served by a particular version of a myth.

Conclusion

The Asdiwal study demonstrates Lévi-Strauss’s major achievement: revealing a common logic beneath apparently unrelated domains of culture. It shows how myths symbolically organise and attempt to mediate contradictions embedded in ecology, economy and kinship.

Yet structural analysis becomes incomplete when detached from history, performance, agency and power. Its greatest value lies not as a total explanation of mythology, but as a powerful method for uncovering the relational and transformational organisation of mythical thought.

2026 How is the theory of structuralism helpful in understanding the concepts of caste and gender? 2026 Critically discuss how culture determines human behaviour in the light of Leslie White's theory. 2026 Compare Edmund Leach's structuralism with interpretive anthropology of Clifford Geertz. 2026 Discuss, with appropriate examples, how basic personality types may lead towards building up of national character.

Want feedback on your answer?

Join the Anthropology workshop or get structured answer-writing guidance from VAID ICS.

Join Workshop Contact VAID ICS

UPSC Anthropology Optional 2024 — Paper I

28 questions

1(a) Attributes of culture

10 Marks150 words
Syllabus: Paper I > Nature of Culture > Characteristics of Culture > Attributes of culture
2024Paper ICulture & SocietyModel answer available

5(d) Authority and forms of political organization

10 Marks150 words
Syllabus: Paper I > Political Organization and Social Control > Power, Authority and Legitimacy > Band, tribe, chiefdom, state
2024Paper IEconomic & Political AnthropologyModel answer available

5(a) Chronometric dating

10 Marks150 words
Syllabus: Paper I > Prehistoric Archaeology > Chronology and Dating > Chronometric (absolute) dating methods
2024Paper IPrehistoric ArchaeologyModel answer available

5(b) Cultural relevance of the Kula

10 Marks150 words
Syllabus: Paper I > Economic Organization > Reciprocity and Exchange > Kula ring
2024Paper IEconomic & Political AnthropologyModel answer available

1(b) Harappan maritime trade

10 Marks150 words
Syllabus: Paper I > Prehistoric Archaeology > Chalcolithic and Bronze Age > Harappan civilization; maritime trade
2024Paper IPrehistoric ArchaeologyModel answer available

1(e) Hemoglobin in health and disease

10 Marks150 words
Syllabus: Paper I > Human Genetics > Genetic Polymorphism > Haemoglobinopathies; health and disease
2024Paper IHuman Genetics & Human BiologyModel answer available

5(c) Heritability and its estimation

10 Marks150 words
Syllabus: Paper I > Human Genetics > Quantitative Genetics > Heritability and its estimation
2024Paper IHuman Genetics & Human BiologyModel answer available

1(d) Lethal and sublethal genes

10 Marks150 words
Syllabus: Paper I > Human Genetics > Mendelian Genetics in Man > Lethal and sublethal genes
2024Paper IHuman Genetics & Human BiologyModel answer available

5(e) Single-gene mutation disorders in man

10 Marks150 words
Syllabus: Paper I > Human Genetics > Mutation and Genetic Disorders > Single-gene disorders
2024Paper IHuman Genetics & Human BiologyModel answer available