VAID'S ICS – Best UPSC Anthropology Coaching in Delhi Since 1985

Comprehensive Classroom Course · Admissions openRegister now
+91 93113 37737
  • +91-93113 37737, +91-99999 46748
  • 73(FF), Old Rajender Nagar Market, Delhi - 110060
  • MON to SUN 9.00 am - 6.00 pm
Facebook Youtube Instagram
Menu
Enquire Now
Home/Anthropology/Mains PYQ/2025/Paper II/Tribal Development, Policy & Safeguards
UPSC MainsAnthropology Optional Paper II 2025 20 Marks Model Answer Available

Contemporary Limitations in Tribal Development — 2025 Paper II

Question · 2025 · Paper II · 20 Marks

Identify the contemporary limitations in the process of tribal development. How can anthropological knowledge contribute in this process?

Model Answer

VAID ICS

Introduction

Post-Independence tribal policy has moved between protection, integration and development. Yet the Xaxa Committee (2014) found that Scheduled Tribes remain disproportionately affected by poverty, displacement and weak access to public services. The central limitation is not an absence of schemes but a mismatch between centralised development and tribal rights, institutions and ecological realities.

Contemporary limitations

  • Homogenising planning: More than 700 ST communities are treated through uniform targets, ignoring differences between pastoral, shifting-cultivating, forest-dependent, settled and urban tribal populations.
  • Land alienation and displacement: Mining, dams, conservation projects and infrastructure separate people from land, forests and sacred landscapes. Compensation rarely restores common-property resources and social networks.
  • Weak implementation of rights: PESA, the Forest Rights Act and Fifth Schedule protections are often bypassed; Gram Sabha consent becomes procedural rather than substantive.
  • Administrative fragmentation: Tribal Sub-Plan funds, line departments and special agencies operate with poor coordination, vacancies and expenditure-oriented evaluation.
  • Culturally unsuitable services: Monolingual schooling increases early dropout; distant health facilities and disrespect for indigenous knowledge reduce trust.
  • Market and livelihood vulnerability: Debt, low prices for minor forest produce, contractor control and seasonal migration create new dependence.
  • Conflict and securitisation: In some central Indian and north-eastern regions, insurgency and militarisation shrink civic space and interrupt development.
  • Internal exclusion: Women, PVTGs, displaced households and smaller clans may be excluded by both external agencies and dominant local elites.
  • Data deficit: Census categories and scheme dashboards rarely capture seasonal mobility, customary tenure, food systems or qualitative well-being.

Contribution of anthropological knowledge

  • Ethnographic diagnosis: Long-term fieldwork reveals emic priorities, social boundaries, kinship, leadership, gender relations and the meaning of land beyond market value.
  • Participatory and action anthropology: Following Sol Tax’s action anthropology, researchers can facilitate community-defined options rather than prescribe a single path.
  • Culturally appropriate institutions: Customary councils, dormitories, festivals and collective labour can support education, health and natural-resource management, while discriminatory features are critically reformed.
  • Social-impact assessment: Genealogies, settlement histories and resource mapping identify who will lose land, commons, ritual sites and social support before a project begins.
  • Medical and nutritional anthropology: Collaboration with healers, mother-tongue communication and local food biodiversity improve acceptance and outcomes.
  • Education: Bilingual materials and community teachers connect formal learning with oral history and ecological knowledge.
  • Mediation and monitoring: Anthropologists can translate between administration and community, monitor unintended effects and evaluate dignity, autonomy and cultural continuity - not expenditure alone.

Critical safeguards

Anthropology itself has colonial legacies. The expert must not romanticise isolation, speak over indigenous people or become an administrative broker. Research requires informed consent, data sovereignty, collaborative interpretation and representation of women and marginal sections. Elwin’s protective integration and Nehru’s Tribal Panchsheel - development along the lines of people’s own genius, respect for land and forest rights, local administrative cadres, work through indigenous institutions and avoidance of over-administration - remain a benchmark against centralised scheme overload. N. K. Bose’s absorption approach and L. P. Vidyarthi’s nature-man-spirit complex are useful only when updated by constitutional rights and indigenous agency.

Conclusion

Tribal development becomes sustainable when it shifts from delivering benefits to securing capability, habitat and self-governance. Anthropology contributes not by freezing tradition but by designing negotiated change in which communities determine the pace, content and evaluation of development.

Diagram to draw: Top-down scheme -> mismatch/dispossession; Tribal Panchsheel + participatory ethnography + legal rights + local institutions -> culturally sustainable development.

Selected authentic sources: Xaxa Committee Report (2014); Verrier Elwin, A Philosophy for NEFA, including Nehru’s Tribal Panchsheel; N. K. Bose on tribal absorption; L. P. Vidyarthi’s nature-man-spirit complex; PESA 1996 and Forest Rights Act 2006.

2026 Write an account on the contribution of Verrier Elwin in developing policies for the tribal populations in post-independent India. 2026 Article 371A of the Indian Constitution. 2026 Discuss the impact of democratic institutions on the tribal populations of India. 2026 Write an account on Development Action Plan for Scheduled Tribes (DAPST).

Want feedback on your answer?

Join the Anthropology workshop or get structured answer-writing guidance from VAID ICS.

Join Workshop Contact VAID ICS

UPSC Anthropology Optional 2025 — Paper II

28 questions

1(c) Regionalism and Autonomy

10 Marks150 words
Syllabus: Paper II > Ethnicity, Regionalism and Social Change
2025Paper IIEthnicity, Tribal Movements & Social ChangeModel answer available

1(a) 'Soanian cultural' tradition

10 Marks150 words
Syllabus: Paper II > Evolution of Indian Culture and Civilization > Prehistoric India
2025Paper IIPrehistoric ArchaeologyModel answer available